Cricket · Level 2: Elementary · Sub-level 2.4
Umpires and Decisions
6 tests · 60 facts · updated 6 September 2026 · markdown
This sub-level teaches how the two on-field umpires run the game — their authority over the conditions and over fair play, the set of signals and the wait for the scorers, how an appeal works and which umpire answers it, and the technology layer on top: the Decision Review System, the "umpire's call" margin on ball-tracking, and the separate jobs of the third umpire, the fourth umpire and the match referee.
Each test below is ten questions on Insporta. The list under a test is what the questions check: one fact per question, with the source it was written from. Read it before the test, or come back from a wrong answer.
Test 1The two umpires and their authority
The umpire at the bowler's end moves to square leg for the next over and back again, so each covers both positions.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
The Laws make the umpires the sole judges of fair and unfair play from first ball to last.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
The umpires are the sole judges of whether the ground, weather or light make it dangerous or unreasonable to play.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
An umpire is allowed to reverse a decision provided he does so promptly, before play has effectively moved on.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · applied
Each umpire answers the appeals and makes the calls for the events he is responsible for; neither overrides the other's proper decision.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
The umpires check the pitch, creases, wickets, boundaries and the ball before they let the match begin.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · applied
The umpires agree how many balls have gone; a miscount does not mean the over begins again.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 17 · recall
Dissent at a decision is a conduct offence the umpires can act on, with warnings and penalty runs.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 42 · applied
An appeal must come before the call of Time; after that the chance to appeal for anything in that session has gone.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · recall
Suspending play for dangerous or unreasonable conditions is entirely the umpires' decision, whatever the sides want.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · applied
Test 2The signals
That gesture signals a short run, made when a batter turns for another run without grounding bat or person behind the crease.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
Out is given by raising one index finger above the head; if the batter stays, the striker's-end umpire says "not out".
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
Repeated tapping of one shoulder signals five penalty runs to the batting side, most often for illegal fielding.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
A hand simply rested on the opposite shoulder signals five penalty runs to the fielding side, for a batting-side offence.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
The umpire raises the ball above the head to signal that the fielding side has taken the new ball.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
That gesture tells the players and scorers that the last hour of the day's play has begun.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
Each signal to the scorers has to be separately acknowledged by a scorer before the umpire allows play to continue.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
In-play calls such as no-ball are made at once, but signals to the scorers are given when the ball is dead.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · recall
The short run is signalled by the umpire at the end where the batter failed to make good his ground.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · applied
Both a player review and an umpire referral are shown by the umpire drawing the outline of a TV screen in the air.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
Test 3Appeals and the decision
Without an actual appeal the umpire has no power to give the batter out, however clear the catch looked.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · applied
"How's that?", often run together as "Howzat", is the usual appeal, though any words that pose the question will do.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · recall
An appeal must be made before the bowler begins his run-up for the next ball, or (at the end of an over) before Time is called; a ball later it is too late.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · applied
An appeal is a general "how is that?", so the umpire may give the batter out by any mode the same delivery supports.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · applied
Stumpings, hit wicket and run outs at the striker's end are for the square-leg umpire; the bowler's-end umpire should leave them.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 2 · applied
Once an event has been decided, appealing again for the same thing changes nothing and the umpire disregards it.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · applied
Umpires are encouraged to consult each other where one of them had a clearer sight of the relevant moment.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · applied
The fielding captain can withdraw an appeal, and so recall a dismissed batter, with the umpire's consent, before the next delivery is bowled.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · applied
Walking is entirely the batter's choice; the Laws neither require it nor forbid waiting to be given out.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · recall
Not out is a full decision; short of a review where one is available, the players have to accept it and get on with the game.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 31 · applied
Test 4The Decision Review System
DRS applies only when it has been adopted in the playing conditions for that particular series or tournament.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
There is a short window to ask for a review, made by the captain or the dismissed batter signalling a T.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
A side can keep reviewing until it runs out of its allowance of unsuccessful reviews; a successful one is not deducted.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
The figure has moved between revisions and differs by format, so it is the principle that is taught, not a set number.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
Test cricket gives a side more unsuccessful reviews per innings than the limited-overs formats do.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
Clear evidence that the original decision was wrong, here an inside edge, means the on-field decision is overturned.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
Without clear evidence to overturn it, the umpire's original call is upheld.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
On "umpire's call" the on-field decision is kept, and under current conditions the reviewing side does not lose the review.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
The tight limit is there so a review is the players' own instant judgement, not a message relayed from the balcony.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
Once the allowance of failed reviews is gone, the side cannot review again until its next innings.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
Test 5Umpire's call and ball-tracking
The three checks are pitching, impact, and whether the ball was going on to hit the wicket.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
A ball that pitches outside leg stump cannot bring an lbw, regardless of the impact or the projected path.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
Where ball-tracking is within its margin of error, the on-field decision, out or not out, is retained.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
With ball-tracking on umpire's call, the on-field decision stands, and here that decision was out.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
An inside edge onto the pad is a plain fact, not a margin, and conclusive bat-first contact makes it not out lbw.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
Impact outside off stump lets the batter off only when he offered a real shot; playing no stroke takes that protection away.
Source: MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 36 · recall
When every element of the review is conclusively out, the on-field not-out is overturned and the batter given out.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
The umpire's-call zone for hitting the wicket is the stumps and bails with a set margin around them.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
A review made inside the time limit that then fails on clear evidence costs the side one of its unsuccessful reviews.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · applied
The system projects the onward path from the data up to impact, and that projection carries a margin, which is the reason umpire's call exists.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (DRS) · recall
Test 6Third umpire, fourth umpire and match referee
Run-outs and stumpings referred to the television umpire are decided by him from the replays.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (third umpire) · recall
Under current playing conditions the third umpire watches the front-foot landing on every ball and relays any no-ball to the middle.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (front-foot no-ball technology) · recall
The ICC dropped the soft signal in June 2023, so a referred catch now goes up without any on-field call attached to it.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (June 2023) · recall
A referred catch often looked inconclusive on replay, and the clear-evidence burden meant the soft signal was rarely overturned.
Source: ESPNcricinfo · recall
With no soft signal to fall back on, the third umpire now reaches his own decision on the available evidence.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (June 2023) · applied
The fourth umpire manages the spare-ball box, logistics and twelfth-man liaison, and is a reserve official on hand if someone cannot continue.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (match officials) · recall
The referee deals with Code of Conduct matters, over-rate penalties and player discipline, but plays no part in on-field decisions.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (match referee) · recall
On-field umpires report a conduct offence, and the match referee decides the charge and the sanction afterwards.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (Code of Conduct) · applied
The match referee has no power over on-field or third-umpire decisions; his remit is conduct and administration.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (match referee) · applied
The reserve officials cover exactly this, so one moves onto the field and play carries on with two umpires in the middle.
Source: ICC Playing Conditions (match officials) · applied
Sources
MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022) for the Laws themselves; ICC Playing Conditions per format for the officiating and regulation detail that overrides the Laws in international cricket (DRS, powerplays, over rates, concussion replacements, the free hit); ESPNcricinfo for recent changes such as the soft-signal retirement. Questions are authored from these sources, not reproduced from them.
- ICC Playing Conditions (DRS)20
- MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 217
- MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 3110
- ICC Playing Conditions (June 2023)2
- ICC Playing Conditions (match officials)2
- ICC Playing Conditions (match referee)2
- MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 171
- MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 421
- MCC Laws of Cricket 2017 code (3rd edition 2022), Law 361
- ICC Playing Conditions (third umpire)1
- ICC Playing Conditions (front-foot no-ball technology)1
- ESPNcricinfo1
- ICC Playing Conditions (Code of Conduct)1